Police Journal Online
June 2004
Volume 85 Number 3


"serving the protectors"
Police Journal Online Cover
 PASAweb   Index & Search   Top of Page   Comments   Email to Editor 

Trust in more than skin folklore

The biggest organ of the body is the most obvious, but few think of skin as an organ.

Sometimes, the skin is the disease. But, at other times, a disease expresses itself in the skin. And, if people can see that something is wrong with someone’s skin, they commonly remark on what appears to be the problem.

This obviousness of any skin complaint has brought about the trial of many treatments over the centuries, and that has made for endless folklore. Just the names for a skin condition can be many. Eczema is often used in the same context as dermatitis but, in technical terms, the two can be different things.

Various schemes have been invented to “classify” skin conditions, but each has had the problem of inconsistencies and thereby increased the many names for the same conditions. The thing to remember about skin conditions is that you will likely hear as much incorrect information about them as you will facts about diagnosis and treatment.

Check with a doctor if you have any doubt about what is wrong with your skin. And understand what is being treated so you do not run into long-term problems.

Many substances are sold to “apply” to the skin, but prove to be of no use at all. Be sure not to pay good money for treatments that are most likely to make a condition worse rather than better.

While I might describe skin conditions in one way, other forms of description do exist, and are accurate. A skin abnormality is often referred to as a lesion.

Information on a skin problem comes from the type of lesion, the shape, and the arrangement in groups.

The type can be flat (macule or spot), elevated (blister or boil), or depressed (ulcer). Shape can be linear (scratch), round (freckle or ringworm) and take many other forms. If they are arranged in groups (shingles) or spread out (bites), the cause becomes more obvious. They can be distributed around the body – isolated lesions, regional (arm or trunk) – or generalized.

So many variations make the whole issue of the skin interesting, and open to many interpretations.

Most often, the diagnosis is relatively straightforward, but the types of treatment can be relatively few. So, sometimes, the diagnosis can be made by trying one treatment and waiting to see if the skin improves.

If the skin heals, it indicates that the treatment was correct, and the diagnosis becomes obvious (a small spot that gets better with anti-fungal cream indicates that ringworm was the diagnosis). Sometimes, the spot would get better anyway, so the treatment’s coincidental application to the spot might have had nothing to do with the healing.

Commonly, cold sores are the reason for many strange applications. Cold sores are the rash from a virus called herpes simplex, usually type 1. Cold-sore blisters usually occur around the mouth or nose and are often painful. Just about every person who has had a cold sore will have his or her own treatment recipe. Yet, in properly controlled trials, the only treatments that will work are anti-viral lotions (acyclovir) or anti-viral tablets.

Offers of natural products with supposedly magical properties might make you feel better but wont make the sore go away any quicker. Despite proof that many treatments do not work, there always exists anecdotes and folklore to the contrary.

A skin treatment might do nothing, which is very frustrating in the case of a blemish. Pimples are a case in point. The acne-treatment industry – worth millions – is based on the insecurities of adolescents and makes products that do not work.

The cause of pimples is within the skin, and in the way the skin reacts to hormones. Applying lotions can produce minor modifications to acne, but serious acne needs hormonal manipulation or potent drugs, like Roaccutane. But new and varied products never stop flooding the market.

Treatment using cortisone creams is a common application and prescription. Cortisone decreases the swelling of any skin tissue; and most conditions have some skin swelling, so some improvement will occur. The downside is that, if any infection exists (bacterial, viral, fungal), it is likely to get worse, as the cortisone will suppress the immune system. The anti-inflammatory effect of the steroid will disguise the worsening infection and end up causing severe infection.

Some of the different types of cortisone cream are good for the face (hydrocortisone), while some are better for the hands and feet (fluorinated cortisones). Some creams work better in ointment form. Although these creams are commonly prescribed, they should be used appropriately and with caution. Used properly, cortisone creams are the mainstay of the treatment of skin conditions.

Sometimes, even the most experienced dermatologists might not be able to diagnose a skin condition. The approach then is a biopsy – to cut out some skin or lesion and look at it under the microscope. The pathologist can add to the certainty of the diagnosis but, even then, the answer might be inconclusive.

When is comes to diagnosing moles and growths, the biopsy is the most useful tool to employ. An excision biopsy means removing the entire mole and confirming the diagnosis at the same time. A punch, or shave, biopsy might involve removing part of the mole. This is so that any surgery can be guided by the preliminary pathology reports as to how big the cut needs to be to remove the entire mole safely.

A melanoma needs a wide margin around the mole to stop it coming back. But a benign freckle may be safely left in the skin, even though the skin might show some discoloration.

Some skin conditions are part of other diseases, so the lesson about skin problems is to get them checked if in doubt. Do not waste money on useless lotions. Give an accurate history on how a lesion started, and get good advice on how to treat anything.

Acting on hundreds of years of skin folklore could result in the wrong treatment.

Your questions answered

Dr Pearce will answer questions on any health issue important to you.
For his response, write to or fax the Police Journal with your question.
Writers need not identify themselves.

  • Police Journal, PO Box 6128, Halifax St, Adelaide, SA, 5000
  • Internal dispatch, post code 168
  • Fax: 8231 0855

If you prefer to use e-mail, send messages to the associate editor
(brettwilliams@pj.asn.au).



 PASAweb   Index & Search   Top of Page   Comments   Email to Editor 
The Police Journal Online is an official publication of the Police Association of South Australia and is published monthly.
Editors of kindred publications can seek permission from the Editor to re-publish any Police Journal Online article.


Copyright 2004 The Police Association of South Australia




sustance